THE 0 SERIES ·AFL 23-0NRL 24-0Football InvinciblesMLB 162-0NBA 82-0NBL 33-0F1 SlamTennis Slam

Melbourne

Melbourne's greatest players, ranked by an era-fair rating built from real career stats, Brownlow votes and honours — plus the club's complete premiership history.

Premierships 13Grand Final losses 6Players rated 1396

all-time VFL/AFL record · 18972026

Played 2,577Record 1181-1374-22Win rate 46.3%Scoring % 96

Biggest win: 141 pts v Hawthorn (1926).

premiership years

2021 · 1964 · 1960 · 1959 · 1957 · 1956 · 1955 · 1948 · 1941 · 1940 · 1939 · 1926 · 1900

Melbourne — club history & record

Melbourne have won 13 VFL/AFL premierships between 1900 and 2021, the most recent in 2021. The club has also finished runner-up 6 times, losing the Grand Final in 2000, 1988, 1958 and 1954 and others.

Across 1897–2026, Melbourne have played 2,577 senior matches in the data here for a record of 1181–1374–22 — a 46.3% win rate, with a scoring percentage of 96. Their biggest recorded victory is a 141-point win over Hawthorn in 1926.

By our era-fair rating, the greatest Melbourne players are led by Ivor Warne-Smith (100), Fred Fanning (100), Don Cordner (100), Peter Moore (100) and Jim Stynes (100). In all, 1,396 players who pulled on the Melbourne jumper are rated here, ranked below by how they measured against their own contemporaries.

Greatest Melbourne players

1
Ivor Warne-Smith
1910s–1930s · 146 games · midfielders
100
2
Fred Fanning
1940s · 104 games · forwards
100
3
Don Cordner
1940s–1950s · 166 games · defenders
100
4
Peter Moore
1970s–1980s · 77 games · rucks
100
5
Jim Stynes
1980s–1990s · 264 games · rucks
100
6
Max Gawn
2010s–2020s · 266 games · rucks
100
7
Steven May
2010s–2020s · 128 games · defenders
98
8
Jack Leith
1890s–1910s · 133 games · forwards
97
9
Ron Barassi
1950s–1960s · 204 games · midfielders
97
10
Denis Cordner
1940s–1950s · 152 games · defenders
95
11
John Beckwith
1950s–1960s · 176 games · defenders
95
12
Brodie Grundy
2010s–2020s · 17 games · rucks
95
13
Kelvin Templeton
1970s–1980s · 34 games · forwards
94
14
Harry Brereton
1900s–1920s · 85 games · forwards
93
15
Norm Smith
1930s–1950s · 210 games · forwards
93
16
Jeff White
1990s–2000s · 236 games · rucks
93
17
Clayton Oliver
2010s–2020s · 205 games · midfielders
93
18
Bob Johnson
1950s–1960s · 140 games · forwards
92
19
Hassa Mann
1950s–1960s · 178 games · forwards
92
20
Greg Wells
1960s–1980s · 224 games · midfielders
92
21
Garry Lyon
1980s–1990s · 226 games · forwards
92
22
Stuart Spencer
1950s · 122 games · midfielders
91
23
Christian Petracca
2010s–2020s · 212 games · midfielders
91
24
Roy Park
1910s · 13 games · forwards
90
25
Bert Chadwick
1920s · 141 games · defenders
90
26
Gerard Healy
1970s–1990s · 130 games · midfielders
90
27
Dick Taylor
1920s–1930s · 164 games · defenders
90
28
Stan Alves
1960s–1970s · 226 games · defenders
90
29
Shane McGrath
1940s–1950s · 118 games · defenders
89
30
Don Williams
1950s–1960s · 205 games · defenders
89

advertisement

BUILD AN ALL-TIME MELBOURNE 23 →

all clubs · premiership history · honour roll