James Sicily

James Sicily played 197 senior AFL games for Hawthorn between 2015 and 2026, lining up most often as a defender. On 23-0, James Sicily's career spans 2 decades, from the 2010s to the 2020s of football.

Our era-fair model rates James Sicily at a peak of 91 out of 100, reached in the 2020s. That figure measures James Sicily only against the players of that same era — the teammates and opponents actually faced — using standardised output, honours and finals impact, so a 2020s defender can be compared fairly with players from any other decade of the game.

Honours on the record for James Sicily include 1 All-Australian selection. James Sicily also polled 52 Brownlow votes across the career.

Season by season, the data credits James Sicily with a best season of 524 disposals in 2022, 77 career goals and a top Brownlow year of 12 votes in 2023. The full year-by-year breakdown is below.